Remedial Diplomacy

The point is not to reward one’s enemies and ­punish one’s friends.

BY Seth Cropsey

March 22, 2010, Vol. 15, No. 26

 

Today in Health Care Reform

Laying the New Foundation, brick by brick.

BY Matthew Continetti

What Democrats Think of the American People

Not much.

BY William Kristol

McChrystal Contradicts Holder

The general is no fool.

BY William Kristol

Obama Just Says No to Soros

Drug-war funding has actually increased on his watch.

BY John P. Walters

March 22, 2010, Vol. 15, No. 26

For anyone who feared that the Obama administration would abandon efforts to control illegal drugs, the president’s first year in office has been on balance reassuring.

MORE FEATURES

Petraeus on Iran & al Qaeda

A dangerous relationship.

BY Thomas Joscelyn

The American People Versus Obamacare

And the 40 House Democrats to watch.

BY Jeffrey H. Anderson

Requiem for a Lightweight

The final days of Barbara Boxer?

BY K. E. Grubbs Jr.

March 22, 2010, Vol. 15, No. 26

You’re a California Republican and, this being an election year, anxiety is mounting. Your state endures unspeakable economic crises, mostly caused by the union-Democratic axis of Sacramento. Unemployment numbers are higher than the national average, and you’re hearing financial experts declare your deficit-plagued, once-golden state to be in worse shape than—oh the indignity!—Greece.

Dead Congress Walking

The Democrats are afraid of the voters and mad at each other. Their vaunted health care reform is going to do them in.

BY Noemie Emery

March 22, 2010, Vol. 15, No. 26

The Anti-Jobs Bill

Obamacare would badly undermine America’s economic prospects.

BY James C. Capretta and Yuval Levin

March 22, 2010, Vol. 15, No. 26

 

After a year of debate and legislative scheming, President Obama and congressional Democrats are making one last push for their ill-conceived health care plan. Fittingly, the endgame is as unseemly as the various maneuvers and backroom deals that got them this far. 

HCR Countdown: Rep. Michael Burgess on Bipartisanship and Transparency

The former physician sheds light on the process.

BY Matthew Continetti

Happy Hour Links

7:19 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Daniel Halper

Fred Barnes: The Health-Care Wars Are Only Beginning. 

Michael Barone: "The House voted this afternoon by a 222-203 margin to pass the 'Slaughter solution' rule authorizing a single vote on the Senate health care bill which the House leadership wants to send to the president for signature plus the reconciliation health measure the House leadership wants to send to the Senate."


CBO: Obamacare Would Cost Over $2 Trillion

6:36 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Jeffrey H. Anderson

The CBO’s most recent analysis is out, and it’s not likely to convince wavering House Democrats to jump to the Obamacare side of the fence.  Even the Democrats are granting that the latest version of their proposed health care overhaul would cost $69 billion more than the previous version.  According to the CBO, this version would siphon even more money out of Medicare, make even further cuts to Medicare Advantage, and levy even higher taxes and fines on the American people.

Media Malpractice: WashPost Reports that All 59,000 Nuns in the U.S. Support Obamacare

6:35 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY John McCormack

E.J. Dionne is pretty excited that NETWORK, an organization of Catholic nuns, supports the Senate health care bill and says it doesn't use federal dollars to pay for abortions. That claim isn't true (more on that soon), but the endorsement is supposed to give Democrats cover to vote for the bill.


Rep. Betsy Markey Moves from 'No' to 'Yes'

5:45 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Mary Katharine Ham

The Fort Collins Coloradoan:

"I have very closely taken a look at the compromise version, I read the (Congressional Budget Office) budget analysis today and I have decided that I am going to support this bill and vote for the bill," the Fort Collins Democrat said.

Her home paper, The Denver Post, on the bill, last week:


HCR Countdown: Where's Biden?

The not-so-dynamic duo.
4:51 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

A perspicacious reader writes:

What, of course, is interesting about the arm twisting of undecided congressmen is how little Joe Biden is involved. You would think a guy who was in Congress for forever would be able to convince colleagues, or at least would be tasked with such an assignment. That Obama is doing it personally reflects little confidence in Biden and also a micro-managing of the legislation he refused to be involved in drafting and ironing out. Compare with Bush, who delegated this responsibility to Cheney, who was apparently far more effective than either Biden or Obama. Certainly his victories were less public so there were not quite so many process stories, which seem like the only articles coming out of the White House any more.

One possibility: Obama doesn't want Biden anywhere near Congress because he fears our intrepid vice president, God love him, would make yet another silly gaffe.


HCR Countdown: The Last Command

If health care reform is Waterloo, is Obama Napoleon or Wellington?
4:40 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

Let's set the table. You can read the reconciliation text here. The preliminary CBO analysis is here.


Coburn to House Dems: Go Ahead, Make My Day

The one and only.
3:12 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

Dr. Coburn speaks. But will Democrats listen?


MA Rep. Stephen Lynch is a No

Counting the votes.
2:36 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Daniel Halper

Rep. Stephen Lynch has just released the following statement:

Congressman Lynch does not support the Senate version of healthcare reform because it has stripped most of the serious reform from the House version of the bill and rewards insurance companies instead.


Obama to Stay in DC

What does it say about the chances for passage? Not much.
2:15 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

As MKH notes below, Obama has postponed his Asia trip until June. Liberals are excited; surely Obama wouldn't have canceled the trip unless he was assured the bill would pass. I mean, it's not like he's been embarrassed by a last-minute travel decision before ... 



Unions, the Cadillac Tax, and the CBO

Why isn't labor screaming about the excise tax?
1:57 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

In order to obtain a friendly CBO score, the Democrats lowered the threshold at which health insurance plans will be subject to the excise tax. That threshold is now pegged at inflation, which means more and more plans will be subject to bracket creep over time.

Yet labor coalition Change to Win says it supports the revised Senate bill. And AFL-CIO boss Richard Trumka is in talks with his executive committee over the changes to the tax. The AFL-CIO is expected to support the bill, as well, despite the changes. Why?

Yesterday Trumka was summoned to an unscheduled meeting at the White House. One wonders what he was told. Could it have been that the regressive changes to the taxes and subsidies shouldn't sway his support for the bill, since the Democrats can always cancel them once they kick down the door?


Obama Postpones Indonesia Trip, 'Will Sign' Bill Passed With 'Deem-and-Pass'

1:11 PM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Mary Katharine Ham

In his press conference today, the first held in the Rose Garden, Robert Gibbs announced that Obama will push off his trip to Indonesia and Australia to June so that he can be around for the health-care reform vote, expected to happen Sunday.

"The president greatly regrets the delay," Gibbs said. "But passage of health care reform is of paramount importance, and the president is determined to see this battle through."


Report: Rep. Michael Arcuri Goes from 'Yes' to 'No' on Health Care

11:49 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Mary Katharine Ham

From Hotline:

A key House Dem has begun informing party leaders he plans to vote against health care legislation both on the House floor and in the rules committee, on which he sits.

Rep. Michael Arcuri (D-NY), a sophomore Dem who had a tougher-than-expected re-election bid in '08, has told the Dem caucus he will vote against the bill.


Preliminary CBO Numbers Are In (BUMPED & UPDATED, 11:30 a.m.)

But they're only preliminary.
11:33 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

House majority leader Steny Hoyer has informed his colleagues of the CBO health bill score. Politico reports

The bill would cost $940 billion, and reduce the deficit by $130 billion over the first 10 years and $1.2 trillion in the second 10 years. The deficit numbers Democrats have been most worried about, and will be key to convincing moderates to coming on board with the bill.

Keep in mind that the second decade estimate is incredibly speculative. Overall, though, this score may move some undecided congressmen into the Yes column. Whether those congressmen will be members who voted No last year is another question entirely, however. Perhaps they will have seen this video:


More CBO details, and the final reconciliation language, are expected later today. A Sunday morning vote is now likely. Gentlemen: Start your engines! The countdown has begun.


The CBO Score: To Be Continued...

11:28 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Mary Katharine Ham

The link to the full, new CBO score is, here (PDF).

But this is health care. There is never any sense of closure or finality to be had, so I give you the CBO's up-front caveat about this score:


Quote of the Day (So Far!)

Robert Darnton on the secret history of the blog.
10:37 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

Historian Robert Darnton on early modern blogs:

Short, scurrilous abuse proliferated in all sorts of communication systems: taunts scribbled on palazzi during the feuds of Renaissance Italy, ritual insult known as “playing the dozens” among African Americans, posters carried in demonstrations against despotic regimes, and graffiti on many occasions such as the uprising in Paris of May–June 1968 (one read “Voici la maison d’un affreux petit bourgeois”). When expertly mixed, provocation and pithiness could be dynamite—the verbal or written equivalent of Molotov cocktails.

This subject deserves more study, because for all of their explosiveness, the blog-like elements in earlier eras of communication tend to be ignored by sociologists, political scientists, and historians who concentrate on full-scale texts and formal discourse.

To appreciate the importance of a pre-modern blog, consult a database such as Eighteenth Century Collections Online and download a newspaper from eighteenth-century London. It will have no headlines, no bylines, no clear distinction between news and ads, and no spatial articulation in the dense columns of type, aside from one crucial ingredient: the paragraph. Paragraphs were self-sufficient units of news. They had no connection with one another, because writers and readers had no concept of a news “story” as a narrative that would run for more than a few dozen words. News came in bite-sized bits, often “advices” of a sober nature—the arrival of a ship, the birth of an heir to a noble title—until the 1770s, when they became juicy. Pre-modern scandal sheets appeared, exploiting the recent discovery about the magnetic pull of news toward names. As editors of the Morning Postand the Morning Herald, two men of the cloth, the Reverend Henry Bate (known as “the Reverend Bruiser”) and the Reverend William Jackson (known as “Dr. Viper”) packed their paragraphs with gossip about the great, and this new kind of news sold like hotcakes. Much of it came from a bountiful source: the coffee house.

Fantastic stuff. And almost as gripping as this story about a surfing alpaca.


Pew: 48 Percent Oppose Health Bill

Congress and Obama are in trouble.
10:05 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

More bad news for Democrats in the latest Pew survey. Forty-eight percent oppose the health bill, 38 percent approve. Obama's job approval is down to 46 percent, with 43 percent disapproval. A majority says health care costs will increase despite passage of health care reform. Ask voters what they think of Congress, and the four words you are most likely to hear are “dysfunctional,” “corrupt,” “self-serving,” and “inept.” "Tickle fight" didn't make the cut.

On a brighter note, the public continues to admire and like Obama personally, even if they are deeply divided when evaluating his job performance. And voters also say the war in Afghanistan is improving. Prosecution of the war there continues to be one of the president's strongest issues.

Even so, the more time the Democrats spend on health care, the worse their political situation becomes. A new PPP poll gives the GOP a three-point lead in the generic ballot. Republicans are intensely enthusiastic about the midterm election while Democrats are not. Obama's Gallup numbers are no good. And yet the Democrats press on and on and on.


Today in Health Care Reform

Laying the New Foundation, brick by brick.
9:40 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

The Democrats' race to pass health care reform is getting exhausting. It's not only the constant rush of developments to the story. The poor undecided congressmen are also tuckered out:

Rep. Jason Altmire has met with President Obama twice this month and received a phone call from Air Force One. Two planes circled his western Pennsylvania district, trailing banners urging him to vote against the health-care bill. And conservative "tea party" activists confronted him at his office, trying to force him to answer: "Are you for or against the bill?"

The pressure has been extreme over the past two weeks on Altmire and the few dozen House Democrats who say they still have not decidedhow they will vote on ambitious legislation designed to remake the nation's health-care system.

Says Bart Stupak: “All the phones are unplugged at our house — tired of the obscene calls and threats. [My wife] won’t watch TV,” Stupak said during an hourlong interview with The Hill in his Rayburn office. “People saying they’re going to spit on you and all this. That’s just not fun.”


Opportunities for Republicans Among Hispanics

The findings of a new Resurgent Republic poll.
9:17 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Gary Andres

A new Resurgent Republic poll released today finds a host of opportunities for Republicans among this fast growing group of Americans.

In an article summarizing the results of the survey, Ed Goes and Leslie Sanchez (both Resurgent Republic advisory board members) underscore the importance of this growing demographic group of Americans.


Is Health Care Polluting the Political Environment for Democrats?

It's getting messy.
12:00 AM, Mar 18, 2010 · BY Gary Andres

If the Democrats’ health care bill were a chemical, the Environmental Protection Agency might label it as a toxic substance lethal to incumbents.  More wavering House lawmakers are realizing this chilling electoral reality as the showdown vote approaches in the next several days.

What’s keeping vulnerable Democrats up at night? The likelihood that even voting “no”  might not be enough to protect some of them from the poisonous political atmosphere that has been building and that passage of the bill could further aggravate.

Yesterday · Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Happy Hour Links

8:20 PM, Mar 17, 2010 · BY Daniel Halper

Lee Smith: A Middle East Without American Influence? That's the logical outcome of the Obama administration's current policies.

Israel's image in America falls. Abe Greenwald takes a look


Bret Baier Interviews Barack Obama

A contentious exchange.
7:15 PM, Mar 17, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

Fox News Channel's Bret Baier interviewed President Obama today. It wasn't what you'd call a friendly encounter. Baier, concerned that the president was filibustering, repeatedly interrupted the chief executive. Obama quickly grew frustrated. Before long, the look on his face suggested he was wondering why he agreed to the interview in the first place.


"Obama's Recklessness is Endangering Israeli and Palestinian Lives"

Yossi Klein Halevi on the crisis in U.S.-Israel relations.
6:54 PM, Mar 17, 2010 · BY Daniel Halper

Yossi Klein Halevi comments from Jerusalem on "The Crisis" in the liberal New Republic. He ends with a serious charge: "[W]hat is clear today in Jerusalem is that Obama's recklessness is endangering Israeli--and Palestinian--lives. As I listen to police sirens outside my window, Obama's political intifada against Netanyahu seems to be turning into a third intifada over Jerusalem." 

Here's the first part of his piece:


Engendered in Beauty

A special series worth reading
6:33 PM, Mar 17, 2010 · BY Katherine Eastland

Via Matthew Milliner's terrific post yesterday, I came across a seven-part series about the relationship between beauty and conservatism, Art and Beauty Against the Politicized Aesthetic, by the young scholar and poet James Matthew Wilson. He studied under the late Thomist scholar Ralph McInerny, whom Jody Bottum kindly remembered in our pages, and is largely inspired by the thought of Jacques Maritain, who, as Milliner points out, is becoming a bit more in vogue these days. Katie Kresser, for instance, has argued for a Maritainian approach to making art in IMAGE. (A good place to start in reading Maritain is Art and Scholasticism, a book Flannery O'Connor read and reread and had several copies of to give to those who visited her for tea and discussion at Andalusia.)


The HCR Whip Count to Watch

Why all eyes are on the lefty Firedoglake.
5:38 PM, Mar 17, 2010 · BY Matthew Continetti

I have no idea what Firedoglake means, but I do know it's an influential left-wing website that hosts one of the better health care reform whip counts. As Byron York reports:

Republicans feel it is accurate, particularly in this sense: They believe that no Democratic lawmaker who is definitely planning to vote yes on the bill would want the activists on the left, in this case exemplified by Firedoglake, to believe he or she is still undecided. Why take a beating for nothing?

The current count at FDL is 205 Yes, 209 No, including leaners. That jibes with other whip counts showing health care reform's future up for grabs.

A major factor in the upcoming vote is the CBO score of the reconciliation bill. The number isn't out yet, not because math is hard but because Democrats are manipulating the numbers to get a good result. Yet word is spreading that health care reform's price-tag is still tremendously expensive. As the saying goes: Know hope.

  •